When a Company Leader Leaves: Executive Search Insight

Key Takeaway: Leadership departures are not exceptional events and should not be treated as unexpected organisational interruptions. In 2025, 168 new CEOs were appointed across the S&P 1500, the highest number since 2010. The companies best positioned to manage leadership transitions are those that use the departure to reassess strategic priorities, communicate clearly with employees, evaluate internal and external successor options, and define the capabilities the organisation will need from its next leader.

Last updated: August 13, 2026

Leaders are essential to the success of a company.  They inspire team members to accomplish great things, by being supportive, sharing their vision and engaging with people.

“Leaders instill in their people a hope for success and a belief in themselves. Positive leaders empower people to accomplish their goals.”

​-Unknown

Key Figures at a Glance

Data point Finding Source
New S&P 1500 CEOs appointed in 2025 168, highest since 2010 Spencer Stuart
New S&P 1500 CEOs promoted internally in 2025 60% Spencer Stuart
Average tenure of departing S&P 1500 CEOs in 2025 8.5 years, with nearly 40% leaving within five years Spencer Stuart
Executive transitions regarded as failures or disappointments after two years 27% to 46% McKinsey & Company

But what happens when a company leader leaves, what do we do then?

When company leader leaves, a sense of emptiness and confusion can be generated around how to keep moving and this may have a negative effect on the entire company’s performance.

We are Zavala Civitas Executive Search Firm, specializing in the Chinese market, and in our day-to-day, we see many businesses in these situations. Here we present you a Guide on what to do when a company leader leaves, according to our experience.

Leadership turnover should be treated as a recurring governance responsibility rather than an exceptional crisis. Spencer Stuart recorded 168 new S&P 1500 CEOs in 2025, the highest number since 2010. The implication for boards is practical: succession planning should begin before a departure is announced, giving the organisation time to assess internal talent, benchmark external candidates and define what the next phase of leadership actually requires.

Acknowledge the change and prepare for it.

First, don’t just move forward and pretend nothing has happened. The departure of a company leader is a major change and any companies lose their focus when this happens (a well-known example is the case of Apple after Steve Jobs left in 1985 and the company started to lose its innovative factor.

So we ought to seize the moment to reevaluate where we are as a company and where we want to be in the future. Where are we heading? To answer these kinds of key questions properly it is necessary to remember the main values of the company and make company employees core values ambassadors, so they understand it better and don’t feel lost at any point when the changes happen.

Know where the company is and where it wants to be.

Second, when reevaluating where the organization stands, an alignment is recommended and it is better if we do it with external help, as it gives us an impartial point of view of what is going on.

This is an opportunity to listen to the organization, to deeply understand it, and learn from it, so we end up with solid bases for later improvement. It is also necessary to know how the company climate is. Knowing how employees feel, their level of engagement. At this point, we need to establish trust and communication bridges.

Choosing a successor quickly is not the same as managing a transition successfully. McKinsey reports that between 27% and 46% of executive transitions are regarded as failures or disappointments after two years. A leadership departure therefore creates two separate decisions: who should lead next, and what organisational conditions must be in place for that executive to succeed.

Take action and work for the future

At the end, we need to decide where the company is going. Provide guidance and orientation. Establish open communication and continuously be aware of how people are feeling and remember that, especially those who are leaving, can provide great insights.

It is also recommended to compare the cultural values of the company and what is actually happening and start shaping and acting upon what we want it to be. These include hiring the right people who fit with what you want the company to be.

Conclusions

When a company leader leaves is definitively a moment of change and we must ensure that it is for good. Always maintain open communication so everyone can move and work towards the same objectives, and always work to make things better but maintaining the company’s

Bibliography.

Harvard Business Review. Jan-Feb 2022. Web.https://www.forbes.com/sites/edwardsegal/2022/01/13/outside-ceo-candidates-outperform-in-house-choices-new-study/

About Zavala Civitas Executive Search

Leadership departures create moments of uncertainty that require clarity, speed and strategic judgment.

A trusted executive search partner helps companies navigate leadership exits with structure and discretion, ensuring business continuity while redefining leadership needs for the next phase.

If your organization is facing a leadership transition, our executive search team can support you with succession planning, interim solutions and targeted search strategies designed to protect stability and long-term performance.

Contact us to discuss how executive search can support your leadership transition.

New candidate being interviewed for a leadership role

Frequently Asked Questions: Leadership Transitions and Executive Search

What should a company do when a senior leader leaves?
The organisation should first stabilise communication and clarify interim responsibilities, then reassess the strategic requirements of the role rather than automatically replacing the departing executive with an identical profile. Boards should evaluate internal successors, external candidates and the capabilities the business will require during its next phase.
How common are CEO leadership transitions?
Spencer Stuart recorded 168 new S&P 1500 CEOs during 2025, the highest number since 2010. Fifty-nine S&P 500 companies appointed a new chief executive during the year. Leadership transition is therefore a recurring governance issue rather than an exceptional event.
Should companies prioritise internal or external candidates after a leader leaves?
Neither option should be automatic. In 2025, 60% of new S&P 1500 CEOs were promoted internally, demonstrating the importance of succession pipelines. External executive search can complement that pipeline by benchmarking internal candidates against the wider market and identifying capabilities that may not currently exist inside the organisation.
Why can leadership transitions fail even when the company hires a strong executive?
Executive capability is only one part of the transition. McKinsey research indicates that 27% to 46% of executive transitions are considered failures or disappointments after two years. Success also depends on mandate clarity, stakeholder alignment, organisational support, cultural understanding and effective onboarding after the appointment.
How does Zavala Civitas support companies when a leader leaves?
Zavala Civitas supports leadership transitions through executive search, talent mapping, structured candidate assessment, reference checking and onboarding support. The process helps organisations define the leadership requirements of the next phase, compare internal and external talent and approach the relevant executive market with discretion. Zavala Civitas has a 92% executive search closing rate.

Managing a critical leadership transition?

Zavala Civitas helps organisations define, identify and assess the leadership required after a senior executive departure. 92% closing rate.

Executive Search → CEO & Board Advisory → Contact Us →

Executive Search China: Industrial Sector

Key Takeaway: Beijing has launched a nationwide “anti-involution” (反内卷) campaign to address destructive price wars and overcapacity across multiple industrial sectors at once, not just renewables. Electrical machinery and equipment, communications equipment, and medical products all show 29% to 34% of firms losing money in 2024-25. Goldman Sachs estimates Chinese

Read More

Executive Search in Italy for Industrial

Key Takeaway: Turin’s automotive cluster invested roughly €2.8 billion in electrification between 2024 and 2026. Over the same period, regional automotive employment fell by more than 3,200 positions. Fewer than 20% of local engineering graduates hold the specific battery, power electronics, and embedded software skills employers are actually hiring for.

Read More

Executive Search in Portugal for Financial Services

Key Takeaway: French banking group BPCE is investing €6.4 billion to acquire Novo Banco and building a 20,000 square metre campus in Lisbon, alongside a 2,500-strong tech hub already operating in Porto. This single deal is creating demand for highly specialised roles in risk analytics, structured finance, and digital-asset compliance

Read More

Related posts

From Rainmaker to Firm Leader: Law Firm Leadership

Author: Beatriz Baker Araujo Senior Advisor, Zavala Civitas Leadership Series | Part I For many lawyers, the route to influence inside a law firm is clear. Build an excellent reputation. Become indispensable to clients. Generate revenue. Develop a strong book of business. Earn the confidence of the partnership. These are

Read More

Executive Search for Financial Services in Mexico

Author: Lorenzo Zavala Founder and Partner, Zavala Civitas Executive Search | Financial Services | Mexico Key Takeaway Financial and insurance services contribute roughly 5% of Mexico’s GDP (INEGI), and the seven largest banks hold around three quarters of banking assets (CNBV). The best candidate for a senior role usually sits

Read More
Legal gavel and books

Executive Search for Legal and Professional Services in Italy

Author: Fernando de Zavala Partner, Zavala Civitas Executive Search | Legal and Professional Services | Italy Key Takeaway Executive search for legal and professional services in Italy is the retained search for leaders of law firms, accounting and tax advisory firms (studi professionali), consultancies and in-house legal teams. The scarcest

Read More

Executive Search for Industrial in Portugal

Author: Fernando de Zavala Partner, Zavala Civitas Executive Search | Industrial | Portugal Key Takeaway Manufacturing generates about 13% of Portugal’s gross value added and employs roughly 850,000 people (INE, Eurostat). Automotive components (around €15 billion yearly, AFIA), metalworking and machinery (AIMMAP) and food and beverage (FIPA) lead, and each

Read More
American dollar and financial banking

Executive Search for Financial Services in Canada

Author: José Carlos (Joey) Hassan Suarez Partner, Zavala Civitas Executive Search | Financial Services | Canada Key Takeaway Finance and insurance account for roughly 7% of Canada’s GDP (Statistics Canada), and the six largest banks hold more than 90% of domestic banking assets (Canadian Bankers Association). Because the market is

Read More
law leaders working

Executive Search for Legal and Professional Services in USA

Author: José Carlos (Joey) Hassan Suarez Partner, Zavala Civitas Executive Search | Legal and Professional Services | USA Key Takeaway Professional and business services employ about 22.5 million people in the USA (BLS), and the country has roughly 1.3 million active lawyers (ABA, 2024). AI, private equity and new ownership

Read More